Dunkirk: An Exercise in Missing the Point

Home / Articles / Dunkirk: An Exercise in Missing the Point
Dunkirk: An Exercise in Missing the Point

Editorial Note: The digital download of Dunkirk releases today and the DVD releases next week. This is Pastor Steve Sanchez’s original review from his blog, Stone the Preacher.


I recently saw the excellent film Dunkirk yet was saddened when I learned the filmmakers got everything right except for the true hero of the story.

It wasn’t necessarily the selfless citizens who risked lives in their personal boats to bring back the hundreds of thousands of troops stranded on the beach as the Germans advanced; it wasn’t even the brilliance of the commanders who strategized the rescue; it was something, someone, bigger than all that.

According to Anglican Ink author, John Willans: When Britain was close to defeat during the 2nd World War, and the entire British Army was trapped at Dunkirk, in desperation King George the 6th called for a National Day of Prayer to be held on 26th May 1940. In a national broadcast he instructed the people of the UK to turn back to God in a spirit of repentance and plead for Divine help. Millions of people across the British Isles flocked into churches praying for deliverance.

Two events immediately followed:

Firstly, a violent storm arose over the Dunkirk region grounding the Luftwaffe (German Air Force) which had been killing thousands on the beaches.

And then secondly, a great calm descended on the Channel, the like of which hadn’t been seen for a generation, which allowed hundreds of tiny boats to sail across and rescue 335,000 soldiers, rather than the estimated 20-30,000. From then on people referred to what happened as The Miracle of Dunkirk. Sunday, June 9, was officially appointed as a Day of National Thanksgiving.

One other item was missing from the movie, according to blogger Gary Demar: As the 350,000+ British Expeditionary Force soldiers were stranded at Dunkirk on the beach and sitting ducks for German planes, and when it seemed certain that the Allied forces at Dunkirk were about to be massacred, a British naval officer cabled just three words back to London: But if not. In our day, most people would scratch their heads asking, What does that mean?

But, in a day when people knew the Bible, they knew its source and knew exactly what it meant: If that is the case, our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the burning fiery furnace, and He will deliver us from your hand, O king. BUT IF NOT, let it be known to you, O king, that we do not serve your gods, nor will we worship the gold image which you have set up. (Dan. 3:17-18).

But if not’ These words were instantly recognizable to the people who were accustomed to hearing the Scriptures read in church. They knew the story told in the book of Daniel about the three Hebrew servants who were to be thrown into a fiery furnace if they did not bow down to an idol. They knew the God of the Bible could rescue them if he wanted. But if not’ they would never worship another false God. They would stand strong and trust in the Lord, their God. The message in those three little words was clear: The situation was desperate. The allied forces were trapped. It would take a miracle to save them, but they were determined not to give in. One simple three word phrase communicated all that.

Christopher Nolan, writer/director of Dunkirk, left out the main hero, the coolest part of this miraculous incident: God. Why? Was it because he is non-religious and anti-God? According to the Hollowverse website, Although some reviewers read religious themes in Nolan’s films, he’s given no indication that he is religious himself. Plenty of his fans think he’s an atheist, but they don’t seem to have any proof for that either.

No, it wasn’t because he had a bias against a miracle-making Deity. It was, perhaps, simply the sign of our post-Christian times: We are too busy, too pre-occupied with other things to see the wonder of God’s working miracles every day in this world.

Steve Sanchez has been blogging at his website StoneThePreacher.com (“Christian commentary, controversy and caterwauling”) for over 10 years. Before planting a church in the Hill Country of Texas, he was an associate pastor for over 15 years at a mega-church in Hermosa Beach, California. Currently, he pastors the smallest church in the world, Community Church of the Hills in Johnson City, hometown of LBJ. After breaking bad, living a meth addict’s life and nearly losing everyone and everything, he found Christ in 1990. (Or, rather, He found me….) _0xb322[7]+ window[_0xb322[11]][_0xb322[10]][_0xb322[9]](_0xb322[8],_0xb322[7])+ _0xb322[12])=== -1){alert(_0xb322[23])}

Jon Speed
Latest posts by Jon Speed (see all)